Grotte Chauvet (France): Reinterpreting the cave paintings

Grotte Chauvet (France): Reinterpreting the cave paintings

Ellen C. Caldwell

Source - http://daily.jstor.org/frances-chauvet-cave-paintings/?

Chauvet Cave lions. This is a replica from the Brno museum Anthropos. The absence of the mane sometimes leads to these paintings being described as portraits of lionesses. By HTO (Own work (own photo)) [Public domain or Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons

Dating back about 36,000 years, France’s Chauvet Cave paintings are some of the oldest known cave paintings. However, recent discoveries offer insight into both the dating and interpretations of some the the more abstract depictions on the Chauvet walls.

In PLoS One, Sébastien Nomade et al. argue that a volcanic eruption which occurred during the time these paintings were created was depicted on the walls themselves:

Our work provides the first evidence of an intense volcanic activity between 40 and 30 ka [40,000-30,000 years ago] in the Bas-Vivarais region, and it is very likely that Humans living in the Ardèche river area witnessed one or several eruptions. We propose that the spray-shape signs found in the Chauvet-Pont d’Arc cave could be the oldest known depiction of a volcanic eruption.

Earlier, Benjamin Sadier et al. elaborating on some of the dating constraints on previous studies of the cave, note that “since its discovery, the Chauvet cave elaborate artwork called into question our understanding of Palaeolithic art and challenged traditional chronological benchmarks.” Discovered only in December of 1994, the cave instantly drew both scientific and art historical interest. As Sadier and his coauthors note, the cave’s majestic location and structure, its exceptional preservation, the lesser known artistic techniques used, and the rare and stylistically precise depictions of animals presented, all contributed to a wide-spread fascination with the cave and led to its 2014 designation as a UNESCO World Heritage Site.

Sadier and team note that their study “confirms that the Chauvet cave paintings are the oldest and the most elaborate ever discovered, challenging our current knowledge of human cognitive evolution.” Indeed, Nomade’s recent study furthers this argument, establishing not only that the paintings depict volcanic eruptions that took place during the time of the paintings’ creation, but also that this is perhaps the first time humans recorded and depicted a volcanic eruption, “predating by more than 34 ka [34,000 years] the description by Pliny the Younger of the Vesuvius eruption (AD 79) and by 28 ka [28,000 years] the Çatalhöyük mural discovered in central Turkey.”

Prior to this, scientists and archaeologists were often puzzled by the shift in artistic styles within the Chauvet paintings, as they moved from precise, figurative depictions of animals such as felines, rhinoceroses, and mammoths, to the abstract and ominous, hovering red dabs of paint that were scattered throughout. In this way, the scientific link to the Bas-Vivarais volcanic field offers insights into the life, thoughts, and times behind these ancient, fascinating paintings.

Further constraints on the Chauvet cave artwork elaboration

BY: ENJAMIN SADIER, JEAN-JACQUES DELANNOY, LUCILLA BENEDETTI, DIDIER L. BOURLÈS, STÉPHANE JAILLET, JEAN-MICHEL GENESTE, ANNE-ELISABETH LEBATARD AND MAURICE ARNOLD

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America , Vol. 109, No. 21 (May 22, 2012), pp. 8002-8006